Not all deer velvet supplements are the same.

Products sold in New Zealand can differ in where the velvet comes from, how much actual dried deer velvet is included, which parts of the antler are used, how the velvet is processed, what other ingredients are added and how much information the supplier provides about quality and traceability.

For Kathy Cane, who has worked with New Zealand deer velvet for more than 25 years, the most useful way to compare products is not to ask which brand makes the biggest claim.

It is to compare the underlying product specifications.

This guide explains the main criteria Canes recommends looking at when comparing deer velvet supplements in New Zealand.

What should you compare between deer velvet supplements?

A useful comparison should consider:

Actual dried deer velvet per capsule.
Number of capsules per pack.
Total dried deer velvet per pack.
Country and farm of origin.
Traceability of the raw velvet.
Which parts of the antler are used.
Stage and quality of velvet at harvest.
Drying and processing methods.
Other ingredients or fillers.
Manufacturing information.
Product testing and certification.
Current price per gram of dried deer velvet.

No single factor proves that one supplement is the best for every person.

The aim is to understand what you are actually buying.

1. Compare actual dried deer velvet per capsule

This is one of the most important figures to establish.

Fresh deer velvet contains a large amount of water. Once dried, it weighs substantially less.

Some products therefore describe strength using a fresh-equivalent or raw-equivalent amount, while others state the actual dried powder content.

These figures are not interchangeable.

Kathy recommends finding the amount of actual dried deer velvet powder per capsule before making any comparison.

For example, Canes states that each of its capsules contains 500 mg of dried deer velvet powder.

A larger fresh-equivalent number may also be provided, but the dried weight is usually the clearest starting point for comparing physical product quantity.

2. Compare total deer velvet per pack

Capsule strength alone does not tell you how much deer velvet is in the bottle.

Use this calculation:

Dried velvet per capsule × number of capsules = total dried deer velvet in the pack.

For example:

500 mg × 80 capsules = 40 grams of dried deer velvet.

This allows products with different capsule counts to be compared on a consistent basis.

3. Compare provenance

“New Zealand deer velvet” can mean different things depending on how much source information the supplier provides.

Useful questions include:

Was the deer velvet actually farmed in New Zealand?
Is the region or farm identified?
Does the seller produce its own velvet or buy it from another supplier?
Can the business trace the velvet back to its farming source?
Does the business maintain control of the raw material through processing?

Kathy considers provenance particularly important because the quality of deer velvet begins at the farm, not when the powder reaches a capsule manufacturer.

Canes Deer Velvet comes from the Cane family’s own deer farming operation in Reporoa, New Zealand.

Canes states that it maintains ownership of its velvet through the production process.

4. Compare which parts of the antler are used

Different sections of a growing velvet antler are at different stages of biological development.

Some supplements use the complete velvet antler.

Others may use selected sections, specific grades or material remaining after higher-value sections have been separated.

Kathy’s view is that buyers should know which antler material is included rather than assuming all deer velvet powders are equivalent simply because the capsule weight is the same.

Canes states that its capsules are produced using the complete velvet antler, including the tips.

Kathy places particular value on the tip and younger sections because of their stage of development and composition.

This is a product-quality consideration rather than a guarantee of a particular health outcome.

5. Compare velvet quality and harvest stage

Deer velvet changes as the antler grows.

Earlier in development, the antler is soft and highly vascular. As development progresses, mineralisation increases and the tissue gradually moves towards mature hard antler.

Kathy’s experience is that this makes harvest timing and velvet grade important when selecting raw material for supplements.

When comparing products, ask whether the supplier explains:

The quality or grade of velvet used.
The stage at which the velvet is harvested.
How material is selected for supplement production.
Whether overgrown or more heavily calcified material is used.

Terms such as “premium”, “A grade” or “Super A” are more useful when the supplier explains exactly what they mean.

6. Compare drying methods

Fresh deer velvet must be preserved and dried before it can be milled into powder.

Different processing methods may be used.

Canes uses freeze-dried deer velvet.

Kathy prefers freeze drying because the objective is to remove moisture while retaining as much as practical of the nutritional and biological character of the original velvet.

When comparing supplements, check whether the supplier states how the velvet is dried.

If the processing method is not disclosed, ask.

7. Compare how the velvet is processed

Drying is only one part of production.

Other steps may include:

Removal of the fine velvet hair.
Cutting or preparation.
Milling.
Sterilisation or microbial-control processes.
Storage.
Encapsulation.
Packaging.

Kathy considers transparency around these stages useful because a deer velvet capsule is not simply raw antler placed into a bottle.

The way the raw material is handled contributes to the finished product.

Canes states that its velvet hair is removed, the product is freeze dried and the dried velvet is finely milled before encapsulation.

8. Compare the complete ingredient list

A product labelled “deer velvet” may contain other ingredients.

These could include:

Other active supplement ingredients.
Fillers.
Flow agents.
Processing aids.
Capsule-shell ingredients.

Other ingredients are not automatically a problem.

The important point is transparency.

Kathy recommends checking how much actual deer velvet the capsule contains separately from any other ingredients.

9. Compare manufacturing information

Ask where the final supplement is produced and what manufacturing controls apply.

Useful questions include:

Where is the velvet processed?
Where is the powder encapsulated?
Are the facilities operating under appropriate New Zealand food or supplement manufacturing controls?
Is the raw material traceable through the manufacturing process?
Can the supplier explain who performs each production step?

Canes states that its manufacturing partners operate under relevant New Zealand Risk Management Programme and Good Manufacturing Practice controls.

10. Compare product testing

Testing can provide useful additional information about a supplement.

Depending on the supplier, testing may relate to:

Product identity.
Microbiological quality.
Contaminants.
Nutritional composition.
Prohibited substances for sport.
Batch consistency.

Not every supplier tests the same things or at the same frequency.

A statement that a product has been “tested” is therefore more useful when the company also explains:

What was tested.
Whether the raw material or finished product was tested.
Who performed the testing.
Whether every batch or selected batches are tested.
Whether the results or certification are current.

11. Compare sport-specific certification separately

Drug-tested athletes have requirements that may not matter to most other customers.

Some supplement suppliers invest in current third-party sport certification or regular testing for prohibited substances.

Others may not.

Canes states that its product has been batch tested for WADA-banned substances in the past, but that this is not currently performed regularly.

Athletes who require current sport-specific certification should make this a separate selection criterion rather than assuming that all natural supplements carry the same anti-doping risk.

12. Compare price per gram, not just bottle price

Bottle price on its own can be misleading.

A lower-priced bottle may contain fewer capsules or less dried velvet per capsule.

A higher-priced product may contain more actual material.

Once the dried velvet content is known, use:

Current price ÷ total grams of dried deer velvet = price per gram.

For example, if a pack contains 40 grams of dried velvet and costs $100:

$100 ÷ 40 g = $2.50 per gram.

This does not measure quality, but it gives you a consistent way to compare quantity and cost.

Remember to include shipping costs where these differ substantially.

13. Compare the quality of information provided by the supplier

Kathy believes supplier transparency is itself worth considering.

A deer velvet company should ideally be able to explain:

Where its velvet comes from.
What part of the antler is used.
How much dried velvet is actually present.
How the velvet is processed.
What else is in the capsule.
What quality controls apply.
What its health claims are based on.

A business does not necessarily need to have the same opinion as Canes.

But it should be able to explain the reasoning and evidence behind its product.

Is a higher milligram number always better?

No.

A larger number on the front of a bottle does not automatically mean the capsule contains more dried deer velvet.

It may represent a fresh-equivalent amount rather than the physical amount of dried powder.

It is also possible for two capsules containing the same weight of powder to use deer velvet from different parts of the antler, different grades or different processing methods.

For this reason, milligrams should be considered alongside provenance, material selection and processing.

Does whole-antler deer velvet matter?

Kathy believes it does.

Her view is that deer velvet should be understood as a complete biological tissue rather than as a source of one isolated ingredient.

Different regions of the growing antler contain different proportions and stages of tissue development.

Canes therefore chooses to use the complete velvet antler, including the tips, rather than deliberately excluding particular sections.

This reflects Canes’ whole-product philosophy.

It should not be interpreted as proof that every whole-antler supplement will produce a particular health outcome.

Is New Zealand deer velvet automatically better?

Country of origin is only one factor.

New Zealand has an established deer farming and velvet industry, along with animal-welfare and production requirements around velvet removal and handling.

However, being from New Zealand does not automatically make every deer velvet supplement identical.

Farming, harvest timing, velvet grade, processing, manufacturing, ingredients and traceability can still differ.

Kathy therefore recommends asking where in New Zealand the velvet came from and how it was produced, rather than relying solely on the words “New Zealand deer velvet”.

How do you choose the best deer velvet supplement?

There is no universal answer because customers may value different things.

For one person, the highest priority may be:

Farm-level traceability.

For another:

Current independent testing.

For another:

Whole-antler content.

Or:

Ingredient simplicity.
Processing method.
Capsule size.
Price per gram.
Sport-specific certification.

Kathy’s advice is to identify which factors matter to you and then compare suppliers using information that can actually be checked.

The Canes approach

Canes’ deer velvet philosophy is built around direct knowledge of the raw product.

The Cane family farms the deer supplying its velvet in Reporoa, New Zealand.

Canes states that:

Its velvet comes from its own farming operation.
It maintains ownership through production.
The complete velvet antler, including the tips, is used.
The velvet is freeze dried.
Each capsule contains 500 mg of actual dried deer velvet powder.
The product is finely milled.
Manufacturing takes place through partners operating under relevant New Zealand controls.

For Kathy, these points are more useful than simply claiming that Canes is “the best”.

They allow customers to decide whether the Canes approach matches the qualities they value in a deer velvet supplement.

View Canes Deer Velvet Capsules

Deer velvet comparison checklist

Before buying, ask:

Where was the velvet farmed?
Is the farming source traceable?
How much actual dried deer velvet is in each capsule?
How much dried velvet is in the complete pack?
Is a fresh-equivalent amount being used in the marketing?
Which parts of the antler are included?
What grade or stage of velvet is used?
How is the velvet dried?
How is it processed?
What other ingredients are present?
Where is the final product manufactured?
What testing is performed?
Is sport-specific certification relevant to you?
What is the current price per gram?
Can the supplier explain the reasoning behind its product and claims?

Related guides

About Kathy Cane

Kathy Cane is the owner of Canes Deer Velvet and has more than 25 years of direct experience producing, researching and supplying New Zealand deer velvet.

Her approach to comparing products reflects her experience in deer farming, velvet selection and grading, processing, product quality and reviewing deer velvet research.

Ask Kathy a question about choosing deer velvet

Health information note

Canes Deer Velvet is a dietary supplement.

Product quality and composition do not guarantee a particular health outcome. This guide is intended to help consumers understand differences between deer velvet supplements and make a more informed product comparison.

Join us for exclusive deals, updates from the farm, and helpful advice!

Deer Velvet Supplements in New Zealand: How to Compare Them